Home About Me

DELRON

The Home of Otter Interactive Fiction

Invasion of the Second-Hand Shirts Reviews
Author: David Good (as DuoDave)
Date: 2002
ADRIFT 4.0


Reviewed by David Whyld (1)

To say it's supposed to be bad... 

It's actually quite good. I even found myself grinning a few times at the downright tacky humour (shame, alas, it came without graphics, particularly in the location where you encounter Aphrodite). Be interesting to see what you're capable of when you write a "proper" game. 

All in all, I know you're wanting a 1 for this but just to spite you: 

6 out of 10 - and I'm even going to recommend it besides!


Reviewed by David Whyld (2)

By far the silliest game on the downloads page, Invasion of the Second-Hand Shirts is DuoDave's attempt at a "deliberately bad" game but, credit to the writer (or maybe not as the case may be), it actually turned out to be quite a bit better than most of the games released around the same time. What the title refers to I've no idea. It certainly has nothing to do with the game itself.

As far as nonsense games go, this game just about has every other one in the field licked: it starts with a detailed introduction which, the final paragraph explains, has nothing to do with the rest of the game whatsoever. Indeed, you start the game actually 'inside' a tree with no inkling as to why you're even there. Think the game sounds a little nuts so far? Boy, it hasn't even started yet.

Escape from the tree and you find yourself at a brook in which swims the Goddess of Love, Aphrodite. At the side of the brook is a leech playing a guitar (how well is never stated). You can question Aphrodite (about the leech) if you want but this isn't the sort of game where a lot of effort has been expended on depth and character interaction so don't expect wonders.

The lunacy continues right to the end of the game - although perhaps 'end' is the wrong word as the game 'finishes' without ever reaching any kind of proper conclusion - you're floating away by balloon(?) to an unknown destination. Then again, it's supposed to be deliberately bad and what better way to end a deliberately bad game than to not end it at all?

I imagine you'll either love or hate Invasion of the Second-Hand Shirts depending on your sense of humour. I'm kind of in the middle when deciding whether I like it or not. On the one hand, it's got the most lame ass descriptions you could imagine, no storyline and puzzles which are notoriously poorly thought out; on the other it's got such tacky humour that you find yourself laughing all the same.

For a game that sets out to be deliberately bad, Invasion of the Second-Hand Shirts fails quite miserably. It's actually quite amusing in a pathetic sort of way although i you're after an intellectual challenge then this clearly isn't the game for you. Play it and judge for yourself. It's certainly not the sort of game you'll forget in a hurry.

Logic: 1 out of 10
The most illogical game you'll ever play by a long, long way.

Problems: 8 out of 10 (10 = no problems)
Where to start? Bugs as such, no. But exits seem to appear pretty much at random, tasks have little or no relevance and the whole nonsense side of the game means that bugs, if the game was riddled with them, would have fit right in.

Story: 1 out of 10
What story?

Characters: 3 out of 10
A leech and the Goddess of Love, neither are very well described (probably just as well in the case of the leech though the game was clearly crying out for a little more description when you meet Aphrodite).

Writing: 5 out of 10
Downright tacky but amusing in its own way.

Game: 6 out of 10
Deliberately bad? No, not really.

Overall : 24 out of 60


Reviewed by C. Henshaw

Cheerful, chirpy, cheeky - hey, that's how I like my games; I'd almost forgot it's been such a long time since I've played one like that ... Duodave‘s small game starts off with an intro that has nothing to do with the game. Sounds annoying, but there's fair warning. And the beginning of the game got me laughing, so the game started out well. 

I quite like the style of the spare, plain locations and descriptions. Some of them belie a certain haphazard programming though. For one thing, too many things are un-examinable. That wiped the grin off my face pretty quickly. There are also sounds that are un-listenable. 

At one point you have a brief conversation with Aphrodite (who is, of course, nude), Then it‘s back to being plagued by non-existent items. A fallen tree is mistaken for the huge tree (which I shouldn't even be able to see from here). In one case, you try to examine something, and it says 'You see no such thing', and then a second later, a message pops up 'Just kidding,...' and proceeds to describe. Cute, but would be much funnier if everything else was implemented, too. 

Unfortunately, one of the all-time game busting bugs ever mars this otherwise fun and quirky game: an object that exists in the room, but isn't listed in the room description. A little something to keep the humour up. Oh yes, and there‘s no real ending, you are (quite literally) left hanging. 

Apparently this is a joke game. And I should've guessed, considering the blurb on the ADRIFT site where I downloaded it says 'This is a really bad game. I guarantee you'll hate it.‘ Etc. Of course, I thought - he's just saying that to get people to play it! But no, it really is bad. Duodave obviously has some comedic talent œ too bad he posted it without finishing it


Reviews should be considered copyrighted by their respective authors.

 

Any donation would be much appreciated to help keep the site online and growing.
To help make your donation quicker and easier just click the "Donate" button and you
will be taken to the secure Paypal donation page.
    Home  |  About Me